Featured Post

Homeland Security: The Sworn Duty of Public Officials

Homeland Security: The Sworn Duty of Public Officials     The United States has a unique position amongst the countries of the world;...

Showing posts with label Course: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Course: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation. Show all posts

Sunday, November 15, 2015

ONDCP' Evaluation

Many organizations conduct this type of self-study utilizing a technique known as SWOT analysis. The acronym stands for: 
  • S = Strength
  • W = Weakness
  • O = Opportunity
  • T = Threat 
SWOT analysis allows planners to learn about the internal qualities of the organization—strengths and weaknesses—and external forces—opportunities and threats—that may have an impact on the organization. 



Assignment 1: Discussion Questions
Are there any problems with ONDCP's goals or objectives? Why?
Are there any forces that you think will ultimately hinder the ONDCP's ability to achieve its stated goals and objectives? Why?
There are too many problems with the ONDCP's goals and and objectives to discuss fully in this format, so I will limit discussion to the most egregious problems. The policy goals were not realistic in terms of results and they were not analyzed via the SWOT model for weaknesses. The biggest weakness of this policy being a “hostile political climate towards clients”(South University Online, 2014, main graphic). Specifically, the clients are every American citizen:

“Despite such warnings, most Americans have yet to appreciate that the War on Drugs is necessarily a war on the rights of all of us. It could not be otherwise, for it is directed not against inanimate drugs but against people—those who are suspected of using, dealing in, or otherwise being involved with illegal drugs. Because the drug industry arises from the voluntary transactions of tens of millions of people—all of whom try to keep their actions secret—the aggressive law enforcement schemes that constitute the war must aim at penetrating the private lives of those millions. And because nearly anyone may be a drug user or seller of drugs or an aider and abettor of the drug industry, virtually everyone has become a suspect. All must be observed, checked, screened, tested, and admonished—the guilty and innocent alike” (Wisotsky, 1992, para. 11). Speaking of admonishment of the innocent, here is what the Drug War ultimately results in: “In Georgia, a SWAT team broke into a house searching for drugs and threw a flash-bang grenade inside a child's crib. The excessive force was disgusting to begin with. Even worse is the fact that the police had the wrong house and there were no drugs” (Rasmussen, 2014, para. 4). I was going to mention asset forfeiture as another punishment without due process, since I'm going to a seminar presented by the Texas Public Policy Foundation on that subject today, but I think that the last example serves well enough.

Finally, the goals did not take into account the old saw that you can't legislate morality. Like Prohibition before it (for a great read on Prohibition and the negative consequences it had on American liberties, see Okrent's Last Call), the Drug War is doomed to fail; "National survey shows a rise in illicit drug use from 2008 to 2010" (Substance Abuse and Mental Health Administration [SAMHA], 2011, para.1). The policy was, and is, unrealistic in it's goals.



Discussion Assignment II
Among the four tasks, which do you consider the strongest ingredient for success? Provide a rationale for your explanation. Also, are there any other factors that will improve the success of the program or policy that were not discussed in the textbook? Discuss.
The most important task is studying; without correct knowledge, the information that is communicated will be wrong, the people carrying out the activities will be spinning their wheels on activity that is wrong, and efforts to balance the needs of the environment with the capacity of the organization will be based on wrong parameters.

I will echo Glenn on the importance of organizational leadership as a factor in making planned change work. Sometimes it takes a little human understanding to make pieces in a policy work, and sometimes it takes that little extra push that effective leadership can provide.





National survey shows a rise in illicit drug use from 2008 to 2010. (2011, September 8). SAMHSA News Release . Substance Abuse and Mental Health Administration . Retrieved January 30, 2014 from http://www.samhsa.gov/newsroom/advisories/1109075503.aspx
Okrent, D. (2011). Last call: The rise and fall of Prohibition. New York. Scribner.
Rasmussen, S. (2014, August 4). Nanny-state mindset leads to police brutality. Real Clear Politics. Retrieved August 8, 2014 from http://www.realclearpolitics.com/articles/2014/08/04/nanny-state_mindset_leads_to_police_brutality_123537.html

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal justice planning & innovation: SWOT Analysis. Retrieved December 8, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

Wisotsky, S. (1992, October 2). A Society of Suspects: The War on Drugs and Civil Liberties. Cato Institute. Retrieved February 1, 2014 from http://www.cato.org/publications/policy-analysis/society-suspects-war-drugs-civil-liberties

Friday, November 13, 2015

Fictionland Police Department Citizen Trust Initiative Summary of Research Design and Outcome Evaluation

Fictionland Police Department
Citizen Trust Initiative
Summary of Research Design and Outcome Evaluation

Table of Contents
  1. Citizen Trust Initiative - Research Design
    1. Design Approach
    2. Design Approach Rationale
    3. Pros and Cons of Approach
    4. Complicating Factors
  2. Citizen Trust Initiative - Outcome Evaluation Measures
    1. Objective - Equip all officers with body cameras
    2. Objective - Re-organization of the Internal Affairs Department
    3. Objective - Review of past citizen complaints
    4. Measurement Validity Rationale


In undertaking the Citizen Trust Initiative, we need to validate that the changes we make have positive, valid, and reliable results; we will establish a research design in order to asses the outcome of the program, and assign specific measurements against our objectives to weigh how successful these changes are in relation to our desired program goals.

  1. Citizen Trust Initiative - Research Design
    1. Design Approach – The research design model we will be using is the simple pre-post testing model.
    2. Design Approach Rationale – The simple pre-post testing model will be used in that we are unable to use control groups in our measurement of our program; our target population lies in the community itself, but the measure we will use most often, the number of citizen complaints, is generated from contact with, to be redundant, the portion of the population that officers come into contact; in addition, we are unable to use multiple pre-tests due to the fact that our pre-test pool comes from a “unified” pool.
    3. Pros and Cons of Approach – On the positive side, the pre-post testing model is easy to use, and is the only model suitable for use in our situation; the negative consideration is that this model does not account for confounding factors.
    4. Potential Complicating Factors – The most likely confounding factors would be false citizen complaints generated in political bias and interference from special interest groups; Ferguson and the Zimmerman cases give us examples in which political considerations have developed a public presentation of a narrative devoid of relevant facts in these cases. The next most likely complicating issue is that we have three objectives aiming at the same goal; this may have the effect that it may be complicated to determine which of our three objectives has the most relevance in attaining our goal.
  2. Citizen Trust Initiative - Outcome Evaluation Measures
    1. Objective - Equip all officers with body cameras
      1. The first measure will be in comparing the number of citizen complaints made before the change (pre-test) against the number of complaints made after the population of officers has been quipped with cameras (post-test)
      2. The second measure will be of a comparison in the number of use of force incidents prior to such equipage to the number of incidents after equipage.
    2. Objective - Re-organization of the Internal Affairs Department
      1. We return to the use of citizen complaints as a measurement; however, this will be a continuing evaluation post-intervention.
      2. The second use of citizen complaints will be a measurement of cases that can be validated as justified; the number of citizen claims as a whole can be seen a a measure of trust in the department, while the number of times that we find officer misconduct will reflect how well our officers have internalized our reforms and as a measure of how IAD has responded to the re-organization.
    3. Objective - Review of past citizen complaints
      1. The pre-test measure will be a ratio of citizen complaints against the number of validated complaints prior to the review; the post-test will be a comparison in how many of the reviewed cases were found to be reviewed incorrectly by the previous iteration of IAD.
      2. The second measure will be a comparison of officer discipline cases generated through citizen complaints pre-review to the number of cases after reviewing the same cases.
    4. Measurement Validity Rationale – We justify the use of citizen complaints as a primary measure of trust in the department on three bases; face validity, content validity, and criterion-related validity. The number of citizen complaints satisfies the requirements of face validity due it the value of direct feedback after officer interaction. We are also satisfied that this method of measurement covers the range of public trust in the department, meeting content validity requirements. Finally, we feel that the use of this measure can reliably be correlated with other data-collection measures such as use of force incidents and officer discipline cases.
The Citizen's Trust Initiative must successfully prove to the public that the focus of the department is in fulfilling our criminal justice mission fairly and equitably; to do so requires that objective, not subjective, measures are taken of interactions between our officers and the community, and the consequences thereof.

Thursday, November 12, 2015

“Community Empowerment” Group Neighborhood Fear of Crime Measurements

“Community Empowerment” Group
Neighborhood Fear of Crime Measurements

As one of the components of the “Community Empowerment” program is to reduce the fear of crime in the local area, a first step in planning this component is to analyze the question. How do we determine what the level of fear of crime in our neighborhood is currently at? By determining the current level of fear, the outcome of the program can be measured; the pre-intervention level of fear can be measured against the post-intervention level of fear. Two methods of measurement are proposed; a self-report survey for community residents, and an observational study of people walking/jogging in the community after dark. These methods will be discussed in two parts:

Part 1 – Self-Report Survey

The self-report survey will be sent out, with a pre-paid response envelope, to every residence in the community, and will measure fear on a family unit basis. There is no associated codebook, as the survey is based on scale of 1 to 10. There will be no inducements offered to complete the survey, and no identification of respondents. These parameters allow us to target the community specifically and to standardize responses. The survey itself is presented as follows:

Hello Citizen,

We are asking for a few moments of your time to measure fear of crime in our community. This is to aid the “Community Empowerment” program to determine how valid our methods are. Your response will be anonymous, and will be valuable in making this community safety program work! The questions we ask are of the family as a whole, so please try to check with everyone in the family.

Please answer the following questions on a scale of 1 through 10, with 1 indicating no level of fear, and 10 representing the highest level of fear.

  1. How afraid of crime in general is your family? _____
  2. How afraid of property crime (burglary, car theft) is your family? _____
  3. How afraid of violent crime is your family? _____
  4. How afraid of crime in school is your family? _____
  5. How afraid of minor crime (vandalism, juvenile truancy) is your family? _____

Part II – The Observational Method

The observational method is based on the premise that “feeling unsafe walking alone after dark” is one indicator of fear of crime (Tseloni & Zarafonitou, 2008, abstract). The number of people walking alone after dark can be measured pre-test and post-test in the following manner. We obtain permission from (5) home owners to park in their driveway. The homes we choose to observe from must be dispersed throughout the community for thorough observation. Then the observers make a visual count of people walking alone, accounted by hour, from dusk to five hours past sunset. These number can be compared pre-program to post-program, but we should be aware that seasonal changes can also account for confounds in these numbers, so it is best to perform the post-test in the same time of year as the pre-test; this may mean that for the best measurement results, we may need to wait some time after the program has been implemented to conduct the post-test.




























References

Tseloni, A. and Zarafonitou, C. (2008). Fear of crime and victimization:A multivariate multilevel analysis of competing measurements. European Journal of Criminology:vol. 5 no. 4. doi: 10.1177/1477370808095123

Wednesday, November 11, 2015

Program evaluations

How can the reliability of an outcome evaluation scale be determined? How valid is this scale? Does the scale measure what it purports to measure? Why?

“The reliability of a measure refers to its consistency. For example, what is the probability of obtaining the same results upon repeated use of the same measuring instrument (i.e., test-retest reliability)? We want to be sure that the measure is somewhat consistent over time, and that results don’t vary dramatically from one time to the next.”(Welsh & Harris, 2012, p.182). In this case, we would need to see the ratio of the pre-test ans post-test results remain consistent over several iterations of the program.
Validity is a different concept then reliability; it is the “idea that the measure adequately or captures the concept of interest” (South University Online, 2014, main graphic). On the face validity, the delinquncy scale is valid; if the intervention works, then the rates of delinquency should go down. On the content validity, the scale is valid ONLY if the researchers had found that skipping school, using weed or booze, or running away from home were the major factors in delinquency. The criterion-related, or construct, validity is dependent on self-reporting. There are several issues with self-reporting. Hagan states that “self-report studies may be subject to lying”, amongst other issues (2012, p. 163).




Hagan, F. (2012). Essentials of research methods in criminal justice and criminology. (3rd ed.) New Jersey. Peason Education, Inc.

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal justice planning & innovation: Selecting a research design (2 of 2). Retrieved December 2, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

Welsh, W. and Harris, P. (2012). Criminal justice policy and planning [VitalSouce bookshelf version]. Retrieved December 2, 2014 from http://digitalbookshelf.southuniversity.edu/books/9781437735000







Scenario 1

Is it fair to say that the program, as it was conceived, was a failure? Are there any reasons that ex-convicts who have been trained with important job skills such as plumbing, electricity, and computing have failed to land a job? Would you consider these to be complicating factors? How?

It is fair to say the program conception was a failure. To begin with, there was no empirical basis for the program; to say “it is believed “ is completely different then saying “it has been tested and re-tested”. This is the reason that planned changes are researched before implementation. Such research should have noted that “a survey in five major U.S. cities found that 65 percent of all employers said they would not knowingly hire an ex-offender (regardless of the offense)” (Petersilia, 2001, para .23). In addition, there are other issues not dependent on job skills;”Mental health, substance abuse, and health problems also pose significant barriers for ex-prisoners seeking employment” (Rakis, 2005, p.8). These are not confound issues; “Confounds are factors, other than the treatment or intervention, that are responsible for the observed outcome changes. In other words, these are factors, other than the program or policy, that caused the change in the outcome“ (South University Online, 2014, para. 1). In this case, there were no outcome change - the change agent simply failed to account for underlying factors that realistically impeded his design goal. Confounding issues should not be “accounted for” in studies so as to bias the result of the study.

Scenario 2

Will the death of the student present a threat to the evaluation of the program? Does the drop-out rate present a threat to the evaluation of the program?

The death of the student does present a confounding issue; some students may stop binge drinking in fear of their lives as opposed to being affected by the program itself. The drop-out rate will also affect the consitency of the reported results, unless the analyst can identify any pre-testing associated with the drop-outs and remove them from the final result comparisons.



Petersilia, J. (2001). When prisoners return to communities: Political, economic, and social consequences. Federal Probation, 65(1), 3. Retrieved November 17, 2014 from http://web.b.ebscohost.com.southuniversity.libproxy.edmc.edu/ehost/detail/detail?sid=da792b0f-f642-418b-9715-c17cb133e72e%40sessionmgr198&vid=1&hid=128&bdata=JnNpdGU9ZWhvc3QtbGl2ZSZzY29wZT1zaXRl#db=pbh&AN=5124169

Rakis, J. (2005). Improving the employment rates of ex-prisoners under parole. Federal Probation, 69(1), 7–12. Retrieved November 17, 2014 from http://search.ebscohost.com/login.aspx?direct=true&db=pbh&AN=19951432&site=ehost-live&scope=site

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal justice planning & innovation: Selecting a research design (1 of 2). Retrieved December 2, 2014 from myeclassonline.com





I had meant to post this early in the course; this is a recommendation for software I have been using for research and citations

Zotero is both a Firefox add-on and a desktop application (you can use it if you don't use Firefox as your browser) that saves citation information AND saves the source doc to your computer if you'd like to use the source again or access it offline.

It works well with the South digital library, with one-click additions to your database.  It also allows tagging to organize references.  It also does limit formatting for your cites and bibliographies.

For those of you that plan on doing more research, it is a great tool.

and it's free! https://www.zotero.org/

Tuesday, November 10, 2015

Week 5 notes

Rules for Establishing an Argument for Causality
In order to establish a causal argument to argue that the intervention caused the change, you need to satisfy the following conditions. Consider that A = Program or Policy and B = Outcome.
  • Temporal Ordering: As measured, does the cause precede the effect in time? The research design can ensure that A occurs before B. For example, you can measure behavior before and after exposure to a behavioral modification program. This way, you can see changes in behavior after exposure to the program. 
  • Covariation: Is the cause statistically associated with the effect? If A causes B, then changes in A will result in changes in B. Does the behavior increase or decrease according to the dosage level of the behavioral treatment program? 
  • Ruling Out Spuriousness: Are there confounding effects that may explain the relationship between the cause and effect? Are there factors, such as C, D, E, and so on, that may explain changes in B? For example, is there something else that is causing the behavior to change? The behavioral modification program may not have changed the behavior, but the threat of harsh legal sanctions may influence the behavior.

Week 5: Week 5 - Developing Outcome Measures (1 of 2)

(correlation does not = causation)(underlying factors)

Confounds are factors, other than the treatment or intervention, that are responsible for the observed outcome changes. In other words, these are factors, other than the program or policy, that caused the change in the outcome.

Two techniques to minimize confounds are:
  • Random Assignment Technique or Use of a Control Group: In the random assignment technique, the planner randomly selects and assigns clients to a treatment group. These individuals experience the program or policy services or activities. The planner also assigns specific stakeholders as a control group. These individuals are not exposed to the program or policy services or activities. This way, the planner compares those who receive the intervention with those who do not receive the intervention and gauges their differences on the outcome measure. 
  • Nonequivalent Comparison Approach: The nonequivalent comparison approach is conducted when randomized assignment is not possible. The planner creates a nonequivalent comparison group to reflect members who are already in the treatment group, based on important characteristics such as age, sex, race, and social class. This technique also allows the planner to chart the differences in outcomes between those who experience the intervention and those who do not, for average client characteristics. 
Remember that the strength of the design is dependent upon whether you have a control group—random assignment—or have constructed a semi-control group, often referred to as a nonequivalent comparison group. Without these, the methodology is weak, and consequently, the results can only be treated as speculative.

Week 5: Week 5 - Selecting a Research Design (1 of 2)




Face validity
content validity
criterion-related or construct validity
test-retest reliability
inter-rater
Another quality that is desirable in a research design is the presence of both a
pre-test and a post-test. This allows the researcher to determine whether a change has occurred and, more importantly, what the magnitude of the change is.

eek 5: Week 5 - Selecting a Research Design (2 of 2)




A technique has been created to accommodate situations where random assignment is not possible; this technique is referred to as
quasi-experimental designs and is commonly used to evaluate policies conducted at a macrolevel—cities, counties, states, and nations.  
Evaluating Policies

To assess impact, we want to compare actual outcomes to desired outcomes (objectives)175
Exactly how specific costs and benefits should be defined, however, is a matter of some controversy, and procedures for conducting efficiency analyses tend to be quite complex.177














Sunday, November 8, 2015

Fictionland Police Department - Planning Division Resource Plan: PAL Program Implementation

Fictionland Police Department - Planning Division
Resource Plan: PAL Program Implementation

  1. Introduction
    A recent analysis conducted by the department has demonstrated a rise in juvenile delinquency offenses
    committed in the afternoon hours, between approximately 2:30PM and 5:00PM. The recommendation has been made to institute a Police Athletics League (PAL) program in Fictionland with the purpose of providing supervision and interesting activity for otherwise unsupervised juveniles. In order to present a resource plan, we will need to identify five parameters to implement and and maintain the program: Parameter 1 - Target client population; Parameter 2 – Client risk and need assessment; Parameter 3 – Client selection and intake procedures; Parameter 4- PAL program elements; Parameter 5 - Staff training and job descriptions.


  1. Target Client Population
    Fictionland has a similar juvenile arrest rate to Virginia, where 92.7% of juvenile crime is committed by those aged 13-17 (Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services, 2006. p. 4). Although many PAL programs target ”youth with slightly higher than normal arrest rates” (IMRP, 2009, p.4), we are looking at additional risk factors (see III.A.), one of these factors is poverty; “About 20 percent of children in the United States live in poverty”(GAO, 1996, p.3). Considering these figures relative to the total population of Fictionland at 68,000, which has a population of 14-17 olds at 5.5% of the total population (U.S. Census, 2012), we can estimate a target population of 748.

  2. Client risk and need assessment
    1. Factors for juveniles at-risk for delinquency
        • Restlessness
        • Difficulty concentrating
        • Risk taking
        • Aggression
        • Being male
        • Physical violence
        • Antisocial attitudes, beliefs
        • Crimes against persons
        • Problem (antisocial) behavior
        • Low IQ
        • Substance use
        • Poor parent-child relationship
        • Harsh or lax discipline
        • Poor monitoring, supervision
        • Low parental involvement
        • Antisocial parents
        • Broken home
        • Low socioeconomic status/poverty
        • Abusive parents
        • Family conflict
(Shader, 2001, p. 4)
    1. Needs of client population
      Not all targets will be able to
      participate in the program. “In some communities and despite good relationships with PAL officers, youth do not feel comfortable acknowledging their involvement in PAL” (Johns Hopkins Center for Adolescent Health, 2004, p.29). Compounding this issue, “Some parents are unable to let go of their negative feelings toward the police based on their prior experiences. Not surprisingly, this distrust affects the relationship between the PAL officers and families. For example, parents may be less willing to participate in Center activities, or even to allow their children to participate in the program.” (Johns Hopkins Center for Adolescent Health, 2004, p. 38)
  1. Client selection and intake procedures
    Due to limited resources, we will be using as many assets in place as we can; in other programs, “Teachers were asked to identify 'at-risk' children in their classrooms and encourage them to join the PAL program” (IMRP, 2009, p. 6). We should should assign one officer as an intake officer and to track participants.

                  1. PAL program elements
                    Again, as we face limited resources we will be using as many assets I place as possible. In other programs, “school gymnasiums and athletic fields were borrowed as needed “ IMRP 2009,p 6). Thornton, Craft, Dahlberg, Lynch, and Baer suggest the use of juvenile justice facilities and social service facilities (2002, p. 11). Considering the main focus of our recommended program is athletic events, we can also look to use of city recreational facilities as well. In addition, to help in the planning of activities, we can look to the participants themselves; “They point out the talents of the young people as well as a motivation to involve youth in planning activities. Similarly, youth participants also report organizing PAL activities.” (Johns Hopkins Center for Adolescent Health, 2004, p. 43). There would also need to be an outreach function for reaching juveniles no longer in school, as Thorton et al point out the need to to enlist outreach workers to locate and engage high-risk youths, many of whom are no
longer in school “ (2002, p.10). Athletic equipment would need to be purchased; the primary sport to be engaged in would be basketball as it would require the least amount of equipment to be purchased and can be played in smaller areas that may already be made available for the purposes of this program by the city.

  1. Staff training and job descriptions.
    1. Staffing requirements
      In the Baltimore PAL program, the officer to participant ratio was often 50 to 1; the PAL officers felt that they weren't able to be efficient with those numbers; the Baltimore PAL program assigned 4 to 5 officers per PAL unit, often with overlapping roles.(Johns Hopkins Center for Adolescent Health, 2004). We estimate that a ratio of 25 to 1 would be more effective. This would require 30 officers at this estimate, even assigning each officer additional program duties such as outreach, client evaluation, and intake. At least one officer from the 30 would be needed to administer the program. In addition, one officer would be required to coordinate volunteers and community donations as possible.
    2. Training Goals
      Thorton et al recommend training to intervention programs the following skill-sets (2002, p.22).
        • Communication skills
        • Team building
        • Intervention content
        • In addition, coaching and refereeing skills would need to be taught

    1. Job Description
      “Position requires dealing with at-risk youth in a delinquency prevention program. Qualifications as follow: current law enforcement certificate, experience in working with youth or education relating to youth interventions.”

  1. Element Costs
28 officers at a yearly salary of $46,000 (payscale.com, 2014)
2 officers at a yearly salary of $67,000 (payscale.com, 2014)
75 basketballs at $5 apiece (Walmart)

The yearly cost of this program would be $1,422,000

It is possible that costs of this program can be defrayed by allowing overtime for currently employed officers to come in during the afternoon time frame, or for a certain amount of currently employed officers to be assigned to intervention duty during the targeted time frame.


























References

Analysis of juvenile crime in Virginia. (2006). Virginia Department of Criminal Justice Services. Retrieved November 28, 2014 from http://www.dcjs.virginia.gov/juvenile/resources/threeYearPlan2006/section4.pdf

At-risk and delinquent youth: Multiple federal programs raise efficiency questions (1996). General Accounting Office (GAO) Health, Education, and Human Services Division. Retrieved November 29, 2014 from http://www.gao.gov/archive/1996/he96034.pdf

Baltimore City Police Athletic League assessment study. (2004). Johns Hopkins Center for Adolescent Health. Retrieved November 28, 2014 from
http://www.jhsph.edu/research/centers-and-institutes/center-for-adolescent-health/_includes/PAL_Report-long_version.pdf

Evaluation of the Waterbury Police Activity League (PAL). (2009).Institute for Municipal & Regional Policy (IMRP)at Central Connecticut State University. Retrieved November 29, 2014 from http://web.ccsu.edu/uploaded/websites/ISCJ/PAL_report_FINAL.pdf

Payscale.com. (2014). Retrieved November 29, 2014 from http://www.payscale.com/research/US/Job=Police_or_Sheriff%27s_Patrol_Officer/Salary

Shader, M. (2001). Risk factors for delinquency: An overview. US Department of Justice, Office of Justice Programs, Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention. Retrieved November 28, 2014 from http://www.behavioralinstitute.org/uploads/Risk_Factors_for_Delinquency_OJJDP.pdf

Table 7. Resident population by sex and age: 1980 to 2010: Statistical abstract of the United States: 2012. (2012). U.S. Census Bureau. Retrieved November 28, 2014 from http://www.census.gov/compendia/statab/2012/tables/12s0007.pdf

Thornton, T., Craft, C., Dahlberg, L., Lynch, B., and Baer, K. (2002). Best practices of youth violence
prevention: A sourcebook for community action (Rev.). Atlanta. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, National Center for Injury Prevention and Control. Retrieved November 29, 2014 from
http://www.cdc.gov/violenceprevention/pdf/chapter1-a.pdf

Saturday, November 7, 2015

Week 4 Discussion

Do you think an action plan is required for Oregon's Escape Notification Policy? Why? Consider the policy details provided to analyze and interpret if an action plan is always necessary for implementing a policy?
In your discussions, include the following considerations:
  • What is the purpose of an action plan?
  • Why is an action plan needed with regards to policy implementation?
  • What are the tasks, responsibilities, resources, and timelines considerations in an action plan, if any?

An action plan does not need to be implemented for Oregon's Escape Notification Policy. Welsh and Harris suggest that an action plan be likened to the instructions explaining how to assemble a new computer system or ike the blueprint for building a house(2014, pp. 123,124). In comparing the policy to an action plan, we can see how the notification policy is matches the components of an action plan:

Action Plan
Preparing a Resource Plan - Cost Considerations in Resource Planning
Staffing
Training
Equipment
Office-Related Expenses
Planning to Acquire or Reallocate Resources
Specifying Dates for Implementation
List the activities by start date in chronological order
Assign a responsible authority to each dedicated task
Decide the duration of each activity—start date and end date
Developing Mechanisms of Self-Regulation
Specifying a Plan to Build and Maintain Support (South University Online, 2014, pp. 1,2)

We can note that the notification policy is referring to resources already in place, or existing staff. The reallocation of duties is a specification of a duty that should already be part of the staff's duties. The timeline for implementation is concise; now. In developing self-regulation mechanisms, Welsh and Harris state that “All participants, both staff and clients, must understand their respective roles” (2014, p.131); this policy stipulates these as part of section III. It could be argued that the policy does not fully specify a plan to maintain support from ALL interested stakeholders, but the notification policy does stipulate that “Reasonable efforts to notify interested agencies and individuals will be made by
the functional unit manager or designee at the time of escape or unauthorized departure” (DOC, 2002, p.3)

Because an action plan is the blueprint of “who, what, where, when, and how”, it's purpose is to make clear how these are put together in a planned change. This is needed when a policy does not specify these items as part of the policy. The task, responsibility, resource, and timeline considerations will vary by planned change, but an action plan will organize these items for succesul implementation.



Escape Notifications: DOC Policy: 70.1.1. (2002). Oregon Department of Corrections. Retrieved November 27, 2014 from http://www.oregon.gov/DOC/GECO/docs/rules_policies/70.1.1.pdf

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation: Action Plan Components (1 of 2). Retrieved November 27, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation: Action Plan Components (2 of 2). Retrieved November 27, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

Welsh, W. and Harris, P. (2012). Criminal Justice Policy and Planning [VitalSouce bookshelf version]. Retrieved November 27, 2014 from http://digitalbookshelf.southuniversity.edu/books/9781437735000


Discussion Part I
While designing a monitoring plan for your program or policy, if you discovered that different techniques for monitoring the implementation of the program or policy produced conflicting results, how would you reach an effective monitoring plan?
I would combine use of each of the four data collection methods; as any one method can overlook data that is relevant to the the success of the planned change. Of course, this means I need to allocate staff for observatonal and data collection purposes as part of my resource plan. This staff can also be used to provide monitoring feedback to stakeholders.
Consider that the observation data monitoring technique suggests that, on average, staff members spend 1 hour per week on teaching life-skills to clients as the program intended, but the service record data monitoring technique suggests that staff spends 15 minutes on average teaching life-skills to clients, against the program's intentions. What do you think could account for the discrepancy between different monitoring techniques?
If staff is overworked, or if staff does not understand the importance of record keeping in monitoring techniques, then staff may not spend the time necessary for accurate record keeping. Welsh and Harris note this second possibility; “This usually means more work for program or agency staff, on top of their service delivery duties”(2002, p.156). Welsh and Harris stipulate methods of mitigating these circumstances; ”Recording forms should be structured as checklists whenever possible to simplify usage by program staff” (2002, p.152)
Discussion Part II
Among the different observational data collection techniques—narrative, data, and structured rating scheme, which technique do you consider to be the strongest approach? Which technique do you think is the weakest? Explain your rationale.
I'll summarize Welsh and Harris's description of the three methods: in the “narrative method, an observer records events in detail, in the order in which they occur. This is very much like a diary” (2012, p. 151); in the “data guide method, the evaluator or change agent gives observers specific questions that they are required to answer from their observations” (2012, p. 151); and finally, the “structured rating scheme is the most constrained of the three observational methods. We can ask observers to rate some kind of behavior on a standardized scale or checklist” (2012, p. 151). I consider the narrative model to be the strongest, as long as the entries are detailed. By limiting input in the other two models, relevant data that may have been overlooked as relevant in the design stage can continue to be overlooked, whilein the narrative model, data collection analysts can note how it impacts the success of the planned change. The other two methods are equally weaker in comparison, but can be used in planned changes in which staff time for data collection is limited.
Is it advisable to combine two or more observational data collection techniques? Are there any advantages to combining techniques? Are there any disadvantages to combining techniques? Discuss.
Because structured rating and data guides techniques answer specific questions that the change agent(s) consider necessary to monitor success of the planned change, they should be used in conjuction with the narrative technique. However, the more data collection methods in general that are used, the more staff (i.e. resources) are required. This may not be possible in organizations with limited resources.



Welsh, W. and Harris, P. (2012). Criminal Justice Policy and Planning [VitalSouce bookshelf version]. Retrieved November 27, 2014 from http://digitalbookshelf.southuniversity.edu/books/9781437735000

Friday, November 6, 2015

Week 4 Notes

Action Plan
Preparing a Resource Plan - Cost Considerations in Resource Planning
Staffing
Training
Equipment
Office-Related Expenses
Planning to Acquire or Reallocate Resources
Specifying Dates for Implementation
List the activities by start date in chronological order
Assign a responsible authority to each dedicated task
Decide the duration of each activity—start date and end date
Developing Mechanisms of Self-Regulation
Specifying a Plan to Build and Maintain Support

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation: Action Plan Components (1 of 2). Retrieved November 27, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation: Action Plan Components (2 of 2). Retrieved November 27, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

Measurement Approaches
There are four main strategies for monitoring the program or policy: observations, service record, service provider, and participant.
South University Online. (2014). MCJ6004: Criminal Justice Planning & Innovation: Monitoring Program/Policy Implementation (2 of 2). Retrieved November 27, 2014 from myeclassonline.com

Developing an action plan is like writing the instructions explaining how to assemble a new computer system OR developing an action plan is like the blueprint for building a house123, 124

All participants, both staff and clients, must understand their respective roles 131

Welsh, W. and Harris, P. (2012). Criminal Justice Policy and Planning [VitalSouce bookshelf version]. Retrieved from http://digitalbookshelf.southuniversity.edu/books/9781437735000


Thursday, November 5, 2015

Fictionland Draft

Fictionland Police Department: Citizen Trust Initiative

  1. The Smith/Jones case has demonstrated several issues within the department, leading to a loss of public trust; racism, lack of profesionalism, and a lack of integrity. The Fictionland PD has instituted a program of reorganization and review designed to remove unprofessional officers and ensure a higher level of community trust. We have chosen to implement a program because we have found no issues with our current policy, and we feel that a combination approach involving the re-organization of IAD, the outfitting of officers with body cameras, and a review of citizen complaints will put this department back on the right footing to build trust with the community.


  1. The Citizen Trust Initiative composes of 3 action items designed to review past problems, remove troublesome officers, and provide accountability in the department as a whole.“ This period of innovation has demonstrated that police can prevent crime and can improve their relationships with the communities they serve” (Braga & Weisburd, 2006, pp.3,4) “Recent calls for improved “accountability” of state bureaucracies are a manifestation of society’s increased concern towards appropriate execution and satisfactory performance of public services “ quote Moore (Cabral & Lazzarini, 2010, p.2) “research on legitimacy and procedural justice supports the proposition that police can reduce the conflict simply by explaining their actions to the public.” (Fischer, 2014, p.4)
    1. Re-organization of the Internal Affairs Department“deviant officials may use various channels of influence to obstruct evidence collection and affect the final judgment; similarly, investigating commissions may refrain from punishing top colleagues and turn a blind eye to certain deviations that are considered as “normal” among police officers “ (Cabral & Lazzarini, 2010, p.3) “One of the issues in police management is the code of silence”(Gottschalk, 2011, p.169)
      1. All officers in IAD are subject to transfer to other departments
      2. IAD officers that watched the Smith/Jones tape will be transferred
      3. Evidence logs and witness testimony will be examined to determine who saw the tape
    1. Equip all officers with body cameras(Silver, 2014) Ars Technica discusses four cases in which body cameras exonerated policemen in complaints, including complaints based upon edited footage of indicents.
      1. The entire community of officers, including most undercover operators, will wear such cameras
      2. We expect to reduce both complaints and assaults on officersWe can measure these results by simple comparison with previous data
      3. gggb
    1. All reported complaints by citizens will be reviewed by the Chief's Office
      1. Citizens complaints from the last year will be reviwed
      2. Officers who are found to have committed breaches of proffesionalism or criminal acts will be reprimanded, terminated, or charged as necessary
      3. Either physical or recorded evidence that counters officer testimony will be considered


  1. Target Polulation
  2. How are targets selected and recruited for the intervention?
  3. Define program components such as the precise nature, amount, and sequence of activities—Who does what to whom, in what order, and how much?
  4. Define the job descriptions of the staff and list the skills and training required. “Creating a specialized assignment to address a problem appears to increase the likelihood that action plans will be implemented.”(Brown & Scott, 2007, p. 13)







“policemisuseofforceproblemsthathavealwaysexistedare
finallybeingbroughttothepublic’sattentionthroughmediasourcesand
politicalagendas” (Archbold & Maguire, 2002, p. 225)


“thedefinitionofexcessiveforceisopentointerpretationby
researchersandpolicepersonnelwhokeeptrackofexcessiveforcecases” (Archbold & Maguire, 2002, p. 230)



“Pate&Fridell,1993).Theinappropriateuseofforce
haspotentiallydevastatingconsequencesforthe
policeorganization,thepublic,andtherelationship
betweenthepoliceandthecommunity.Thegoodwill” (Brandl, Stroshine, & Frank, 2001, p. 521)

“officersaremorelikelytouseforce
againstsuspectsoftheirownrace” quote Alpert&Dunham (Brandl, Stroshine, & Frank, 2001, p. 523)







“Success in policing is enhanced when the police can gain and maintain support from the
public. In individual encounters with residents, police benefit when people are willing to accept
and defer to the appropriate use of police authority, rather than starting the encounter with
feelings of hostility and resistance. Further, if people have a high degree of respect for their local
police and the law, they are more likely to obey the law, including relatively minor traffic laws “(Fischer, 2014, p.8)



“Integrity in public office demands open and transparent decision making and clarity about the primacy of a public official's duty to serve the public interest “(Gottschalk, 2011, p.171)












Archbold, C. A., & Maguire, E. R. (2002). Studying civil suits against the police: A serendipitous finding of sample selection bias. Police Quarterly, 5(2), 222–249. Retrieved August 10, 2014 from http://pqx.sagepub.com/content/5/2/222.short

Braga, A. A., & Weisburd, D. L. (2006). Police Innovation and Crime Prevention: Lessons Learned from Police Research over the Past 20 Years. Retrieved August 23, 2014 from http://www.ncjrs.gov/pdffiles1/nij/grants/218585.pdf?q=ideas-in-american-policing

Brandl, S. G., Stroshine, M. S., & Frank, J. (2001). Who are the complaint-prone officers?: An examination of the relationship between police officers’ attributes, arrest activity, assignment, and citizens’ complaints about excessive force. Journal of Criminal Justice, 29(6), 521–529. Retrieved August 10, 2014 from http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S0047235201001143

Brown, R., & Scott, M. S. (2007). Implementing responses to problems. Washington, DC: Office of Community Oriented Policing Services, U.S. Department of Justice. Retrieved November 8, 2014 from http://www.popcenter.org/tools/pdfs/implementing_responses.pdf


Cabral, S., & Lazzarini, S. G. (2010). Guarding the Guardians: An Analysis of Investigations against Police Officers in an Internal Affairs Division. Retrieved August 10, 2014 from http://extranet.isnie.org/uploads/isnie2010/cabral_lazzarini.pdf

Fischer, C. (2014). Legitimacy and Procedural Justice:  A New Element of Police Leadership. Police Executive Research Forum. Retrieved August 10, 2014 from http://www.policeforum.org/assets/docs/Free_Online_Documents/Leadership/legitimacy%20and%20procedural%20justice%20-%20a%20new%20element%20of%20police%20leadership.pdf

Gottschalk, P. (2011). Management challenges in law enforcement: the case of police misconduct and crime. International Journal of Law and Management, 53(3). Retrieved August 22, 2014 from http://search.proquest.com.southuniversity.libproxy.edmc.edu/docview/868256452?pq-origsite=summon

Silver, J. (2014, June 21). Candid camera, part 2: Four times that video evidence exonerated cops | Ars Technica. Ars Technica. Retrieved August 25, 2014 from http://arstechnica.com/tech-policy/2014/06/candid-camera-part-2-four-times-that-video-evidence-exonerated-cops/







Wednesday, November 4, 2015

GED Program Selection Review

GED Program Selection Review

Due to decreasing budget allocations or educational purposes, the DOC has decided to choose one of two programs to assist inmates with securing a GED. The first program is Education First; Education First has a cost of $500 per inmate, and a success rate of 50%. The second program is GED Prep, which has a cost of $5,000 per inmate and a success rate of 80%. GED Prep is 60% more effective as a program than Education First, but at costs of 1000% the rate of GED Prep. Now we must look at the costs of failure; 80% of inmates without a high school degree that are released return to prison, while 40% of inmates with a high school degree that are released return to prison. The cost of keeping an inmate in prison is at $32,000 per year.*
Let us compare the two programs per groups of 10 prisoners:
Education First
10 inmates at $500 each = $5,000
5 inmates pass, of whom 2 return to prison
2 recidivists at $32000 = $64,000
5 inmates fail, of whom 4 return to prison
4 recidivists at $32000 = $128,000
Total Cost of Education First for 1 year = $197,000
Cost of Education First per additional recidivist year of prison time = $192,000

GED Prep
10 inmates at $5000 each = $50,000
8 inmates pass, of whom 3.2 return to prison
3.2 recidivists at $32000 = $102,400
2 inmates fail, of whom 1.6 return to prison
1.6 recidivists at $32000 = $51,200
Total Cost of GED Prep = $203, 600
Cost of GED Prep per additional recidivist year of prison time = $153,600

In comparing the cost per year of these programs, there are two comparisons to make; the first of which is the initial cost, and the second is the cost per additional year of recidivist incarceration. There is a difference of $6,600 per 10 inmates per recidivist year in prison, or $660 per inmate for the initial year of prison time, with the Education First program being the cheaper. However, for every additional year of recidivist incarceration, GED Prep saves DOC $38,400 per 10 inmates, or $3,840 per inmate. To finalize the comparison, the average length of incarceration for recidivist offenders would be needed. However, figures provided by BJS would be inaccurate to use because “Inmates whose sentence was less than 1 year were also excluded” (Durose, Cooper, & Snyder, 2014, p ,17). The lack of accurate tracking is compounded by the fact that this is the population that would prove it cost effective to use the services of Education First.
The interim recommendation is to use the services of Education First until an accurate count of recidivist sentences can be compiled which compares the number of sentences with a duration under a year against an aggregate of sentencing in which the years after the first year were counted.
References
Durose, M. R., Cooper, A. D., & Snyder, H. N. (2014). Recidivism of Prisoners Released in 30 States in 2005: Patterns from 2005 to 2010. Bureau of Justice Statistics. Retrieved November 21, 2014 from https://www.prisonlegalnews.org/media/publications/BJS%20recidivism%20study,%202014.pdf


*All figures provided by DOC